Environmental Health News

What's Working

  • Garden Mosaics projects promote science education while connecting young and old people as they work together in local gardens.
  • Hope Meadows is a planned inter-generational community containing foster and adoptive parents, children, and senior citizens
  • In August 2002, the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) Board voted to ban soft drinks from all of the district’s schools

#43 - Indoor Air Is More Contaminated Than Outdoor Air; Homes At Risk, 20-Sep-1987

Why is it important to reduce the use of hazardous materials (as
distinct from reducing hazardous wastes)? Here's one compelling reason:
Indoor air pollution is a greater source of exposure to hazardous
chemicals than is outdoor exposure, even if you live near major "point
sources" of pollution, according to a careful study by the federal
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

From 1979 to 1985, EPA researchers studied the outdoor air, the indoor
air, and chemicals carried on the breath of 355 individuals living in
the [heavily industrialized] Jersey City-Bayonne part of New Jersey, in
[not so industrialized] Greensboro, North Carolina, and in [not
industrialized] Devils Lake, North Dakota.

The EPA looked for 20 chemicals in all these locations and they found
11 of them at all locations. This is known as the TEAM [Total Exposure
Assessment Method] Study and it was carefully done; about 5000 samples
were taken in all, 1500 of them taken to provide quality control checks
on the data.

Participants in the study wore a small, battery-operated pump pinned to
a vest; the pump drew in air close to the subject's face, providing a
good measure of the quality of the air a person was breathing. At night
the pump was placed on the bedside table (providing a measure of indoor
air). Other pumps were placed in peoples' back yards or side yards,
providing measures of outdoor air. At the end of each day, each
person's breath was sampled. Thus the study provided data on (a)
personal air; (b) indoor air; (c) outdoor air; and (d) breath.

In New Jersey, 11 hazardous chemicals could be measured consistently in
breath and air samples. The chemicals are 1,1,1-trichloroethane, p-
xylene, ethylbenzene, tetrachloroethylene, o-xylene, p-dichlorobenzene,
chloroform, trichloroethylene, and carbon tetrachloride. Averages
(medians) for personal air exceeded outdoor averages for every chemical
in every season, usually by a factor of 2 to 5. This means that, in a
typical day at work and at home (com-bined), people breathed in 2 to 5
times as much hazardous chemical as they would have if they had sat in
their back yards for 24 hours. This was true even if the people lived
within a mile of a source of industrial air pollution.

In NJ, the night-time readings (indoor air) exceeded outdoor air
concentrations in 28 out of 30 cases.

In North Carolina and North Dakota the results are even stronger
(because in NC and ND the outdoor air is cleaner): in 17 out of 18
cases, personal air exceeded the levels found in outdoor air, usually
by a factor of 5 to 10.

The chemicals on peoples' breath were closely correlated with their
activities of the previous 12 hours. People had chloroform (a
carcinogen) on their breath if they were exposed to chlorinated water
(through drinking, showering, bathing, washing clothes and dishes).

Other factors causing increased exposure to chemicals:

Occupation: Employment in plastics, wood processing, service
stations/garages, painting, textiles, metals, scientific laborat ories,
dye plants and even hospitals were associated with significantly
increased exposure to 9 of the 11 chemicals.

Home characteristics: living with a smoker or a chemical plant worker
increased the risk of everyone in the home.

Common daily activities: pumping gasoline (filling one's gas tank) or
visiting a service station; visiting a dry cleaner; keeping moth
crystals or room deodorizers in the home; furniture refinishing;
painting; scale model building; using pesticides; smoking; traveling in
a car--were all associated with increased exposures to one or more of
the 11 chemicals.

Specific exposures are as follows: smokers (and those living with
smokers) have elevated levels of benzene, styrene, ethylbenzene and p-
xylene on their breath. The sidestream of a cigarette provides much
more benzene than does the smoke inhaled by the smoker (240 micrograms
per cigarette in the sidestream vs. 35 micrograms in the mainstream).
About 60% of U.S. children live in homes with smokers and are thus
exposed to benzene, a cause of leukemia. Children with one parent
smoking have a doubled risk of leukemia; with both parents smoking the
risk of leukemia is increased five-fold (compared to children of non-
smoking parents).

Chlorinated water causes indoor air in New Jersey to have four times as
much chloroform as outdoor air.

A person visiting a dry cleaner for five minutes has twice as much
tetrachloroethylene (PCE) on his or her breath, compared to a person
avoiding such a visit. PCE levels in dry cleaning shops are very high.

Moth crystals and room deodorizers are intended to maintain high levels
of p-dichlorobenzene in homes, so no one should be surprised that they
succeed. Recently p-dichlorobenzene was determined to be a carcinogen.
In homes using moth crystals or air deodorizers, p-dichlorobenzene
levels are 25 times higher than in outside air (in NJ).

What can be done to reduce exposures to chemicals in the home and at
work? Consumers can purchase less of the offending products (moth
balls, for example); citizen pressure can force manufacturers to reduce
their use of hazardous chemicals; citizen pressure can force government
agencies to adopt standards for building materials (for example,
particle board is today loaded with formaldehyde, a carcinogen); and
ventilate the place better. Programs to force waste reduction will help
little, if at all.

The TEAM study results appeared in the scientific journal ENVIRONMENTAL
RESEARCH, Vol. 43 (1987), pgs. 290-307.

--Peter Montague



The federal General Accounting Office (GAO) has issued a 36 page
WASTES [GAO/RCED-87-153], which says federal agencies have so far found
1,882 hazardous waste sites on their property but have evaluated only
half of them. Most agencies are still looking. The report is available
free from GAO, DHISF, P.O. Box 6015, Gaithersburg, MD 20877; phone
(202) 275-6241.

--Peter Montague


Descriptor terms: superfund; remedial action; hazardous waste disposal
technologies; epa; hazardous chemicals; indoor air pollution; nj; nc;
nd; trichloroethane; trichloroethylene; chloroform; carbon
tetrachloride; tetrachloroethylene; dichlorobenzene; plastics; heavy
metals; carcinogens; drinking water; chlorination; testing; tobacco;
leukemia; formaldehyde; pesticides; benzene; styrene;